Bexley offers Honors courses in English 9 and 10, Advanced Algebra, Pre-calculus, Physical Science Biology, Chemistry, French, Spanish, and Latin. Twenty-two certified Advanced Placement courses are offered in Language and Composition, Literature and Composition, Calculus AB, Calculus BC, Statistics, Biology, Chemistry, Physics I and II, Environmental Science, American History, European History, World History, Psychology, U.S. Government and Politics, Computer Science, Spanish, French, Latin, Art History, Studio Art and Music Theory. Students enrolled in AP courses are required to take the AP exam, which is paid for by the school district; there is no limit on the number of AP courses a student may take. In 2015, 261 students took a total of 574 AP exams with 86.5 percent earning a score of 3 or above.
A Learning Center provides services for students with identified learning disabilities. Students may participate in alternative learning experiences at Eastland/Fairfield Career Center, through the WINGS program, Post-Secondary Educational Options, Dual Enrollment at Columbus State Community College and the Metro School, a county-wide school with a math and science focus. Also available is MOSAIC, an inter-disciplinary, integrated curriculum with a global/multicultural focus.
Over the past 20 years, more than 90 percent of Bexley students have entered college after graduation. The Class of 2016 had a college matriculation rate of 90 percent with 40 percent attending colleges outside of Ohio.